Scary Story
By Merna Shehata
It is quiet outside. Only a few cars pass by every now and then, and a few raindrops slide down the leaves of the peach tree in the backyard – they are the aftermath of a storm. She lies on the couch, exhausted from the day’s events. One arm is on her forehead and the other falls all the way down to the ground. She feels the cool air circulating around the house as she lies there, regretting her decisions and actions, dreading the consequences, hoping it was all a dream. She remembers the screams, her own screams, as she raised the axe above her head and swung it down. Her eyes open wide. She remembers the whispers that came after, threatening to come back. A shiver passes through every inch of her body. She remembers the shadows surrounding her, the moonlight fading rapidly, until she could only see darkness. A gasp escapes out of her mouth and she jumps up. Beads of sweat cover her face as her heart races at the speed of light. She could’ve never imagined her life leading to this point. How did she stoop so slow?
It was only this morning that she was preparing for her sister’s birthday. She organized everything, made a list, even, with all the supplies she needed to make this a successful birthday. How did everything escalate so quickly? Her eyes slowly make their way across the room to the banner that says, “Happy Birthday, Riley!” This morning it hung high with bright colors; Riley’s name was outlined in yellow, her favorite color. In the darkness, however, the yellow looks dim and gloomy, greenish or maybe even red. No, it will never be the same; everything has changed now, and there is nothing she will be able to do about it.
She begins to notice the changes around her: the rips on the banner, the broken glass, Riley’s torn dress. It won’t be long before they find the body; she knows that she should clean up the mess and hide the evidence, but she doesn’t. She sits and waits, almost as if she is paralyzed, terrified of her actions more than of the consequences. As time passes by, flashbacks begin, reminding her of how she led Riley into the woods, promising her a special gift for her birthday. They had heard of how these woods were cursed all the time when they were children, but they never gave much thought to it. The memories flood her head, and vividly remind her of the crazy emotions that took over her senses and controlled her body. They remind her of Riley’s perplexed face as she watched her twitch and quiver towards the axe laid on the pile of wood, innocently thinking that her dear sister would never hurt her, patiently waiting for her mystery present. She begins to feel heavy and she sits up, trying to shake the sleep off, avoiding another nightmare. Her eyelids betray her as they steadily move closer to each other and she loses consciousness.
The aroma of something rotten wakes her up. As her eyes struggle to open, she realizes that she can't see anything. Is this the consequence? Maybe she can live blind after all. Those are her thoughts before she sees something glimmer in the dark. She gets up and carefully makes her way towards the glimmer. She hears a crunch under her feet and pain starts to travel up her body. By the time she figures out that she has stepped in the broken glass, there is a puddle of thick red under her foot. Suddenly, a bright light flashes by and reflects over the million pieces of glass. Her heart stops beating until she realizes that it was nothing more than a car passing by. She catches something else glimmer out of the corner of her eye. Is that…? No, it can't be, she buried Riley below the peach tree. She moves closer towards the smell this time, hoping to deny her suspicions. The whispers begin when the second car passes by. Riley? The third travels by. You look stunning in that dress! The fourth car drives by. It’s shimmering like glass. The last car flies by. Can you spin for me?
She finds Riley hung like a chandelier in her shimmering dress. Horrified, she watches as the red spreads and takes over the bright yellow. She runs to the window and opens the blinds. The peach tree looks untouched, undisturbed. She turns back to look at the ceiling only to find the body gone. She freezes in place while her eyes scan the room wildly – where did she go? She abruptly turns back to the window to find Riley staring at her with hollow eyes and bony cheeks. A smile spreads freakishly across Riley’s face as her head turns sideways. Sharp glass shoots out of Riley’s dress in every direction as she spins for her sister. Her roaring scream was the last thing the neighborhood heard before she went missing.
Winner of the Highpoint Scary Short Story Contest, Halloween 2020!
The Blue-Eyed Beauty
By Nina Jasanoff
Black rows and rows of dreary and despairing faces gathered around the great stone in the center. It was raining – not raining really, but drizzling – and at the center of the commotion stood a lady, tall and pale, with dark hair and bright blue eyes. She was frowning and a tear rolled down her cheek, though she didn’t look upset in the least. She stood there with her head held high, looking straight ahead and frowning obediently. All draped in black, from the little hat on her magnificent head to the tips of her delicate toes, she struck quite a figure as she stood there in the drizzle of that cold day.
After the ceremony, she walked away with poise down the gravel path leading away from the cemetery. A hand touched her shoulder from behind, and she turned with a smile that came so easily and naturally to her lips. It looked real, but if one looked close enough, one would see that it was entirely false. She had never smiled a day in her life, not once, and she had been taught by the best.
The offender of her internal calm was an old woman, wrinkled and hunched over. The years had very clearly left their mark on this dame’s features, and she held out her shaking hand to the younger girl. “I am so sorry for your loss, my child. Your father was a great man.”
“Thank you.” She was polite about it, and her musical British voice held none of the falseness she knew it had. “I loved him very much.”
The old lady smiled and nodded appreciatively, and excused herself, hobbling away. With her exit, another person came, this time a young man, and stood by the girl’s side. Seeming to sense his presence, she held up her hand to him to stop walking abruptly. He took the hand, gloved in black lace, and kissed it. Disgustedly, she drew away and shook herself slightly.
“Heath, who is that old lady?”
“Mrs. Leonora Hatchet, Alice.”
“I am not ‘Alice’ to you or to anyone, now that Father has died.” She had turned on him and was glaring menacingly up at him with her stern and cold blue eyes.
“You are my stepsister, I have every right to call you Alice.”
“No. Now that Papa is gone, you shall cut all ties with me on such a personal level and call me Ms. Adair.”
“Oh, posh.”
“I mean it, Mr. Glass.” She stepped back and turned on her heel, continuing to walk away from the cemetery.
“Alice, wait.” He had paused to watch her go, for she was quite a sight to behold, and ran to catch up with her.
“I shan’t speak to you any longer if you call me that.”
“Alice – I mean, Ms. Adair – don’t be silly about this.”
“Me, silly. I should think not.” The cold indifference of her first pronouncement mellowed in comparison to the vehement way she uttered the second.
She continued to march away and her companion stopped and watched her go, shaking his head in awe.
A week later had the very same girl in the very same garb at the very same place in the very same weather. It would seem that everyone in her life was dying off. First had been her mother, unexpectedly three months hence, then her uncle a fortnight later, her father next, and now her aunt. Her only remaining relative was Mr. Glass, and she pondered his existence as she stood over the grave of the newly deceased.
That night, there was a knock on the door of her apartment. She bade her loyal maid answer the door, and her visitor ambled in. She was unsurprised to find herself with Mr. Glass.
“Oh, do come and sit, sir.” She motioned with her hand as she stood to greet him.
“I’m not playing games with you anymore, Alice. Tell me why this is all happening?”
“What?” Her face betrayed genuine surprise that her whole person lacked otherwise.
“I know it isn’t a coincidence that your family members are all dropping dead. It can’t be.”
“I shouldn’t see why not. My mother, father, aunt, and uncle were all roughly the same age, give or take, and that should be enough to quiet the matter.”
“They all died mysteriously – some doctors think poison, others think suicide, but many suspect murder.”
“I shouldn’t think why.” She was standing now, with all her grace and poise by the window gazing out at the Victorian streets, busy with people and bustling with noise.
He got up from his seat in one of the armchairs and went to stand beside her. “I’m not stupid, Alice.”
“Frankly, I am rather inclined to think you are.” She addressed him with the cold hard stare to which she had grown accustomed.
“I’m not kidding, Alice.” He grabbed her well-formed chin and lifted it forcefully to look at his face.
“Leave me be,” she sneered. He let go and threw her to the ground; “Ah!” she cried, crumpling in a heap.
“Tell me.”
“Tell you what? I don’t know what you want.” She looked genuinely frightened, though inside she felt nothing still.
“You know very well what, tell me outright that you murdered your family.” His gray eyes flashed. “Admit it. To my face.” He gazed at her intensely and intently, picking out every cold and lovely minute feature.
She arose and shook out her dress, “No. I didn’t do it and I won’t say anything. I know better.” She tried to walk away from the window where they both stood but he grabbed her arm and pushed her to him, grabbing her chin once more, and giving her mouth a passionate kiss.
“Tell me.”
“No.” She said it, but he could see her guard was falling.
“Tell me.” He was now kissing her neck gently, waiting for her to crack.
“No.”
And suddenly, he fell to his knees behind her, and his eyes bugged out as he held the hilt of the sword she had driven clean through him. She stiffened and regained that cold composure she had never really lost.
“Matilda, clean up the mess.”
“Yes, miss.” The maid scurried into the room, “What shall I tell the papers this time, miss?”
The young lady bedecked in elegant black paused, framed in the doorway. “I’m feeling… suicide.” She gave a wicked sneer and touched her tongue to the top of her teeth, walking out of the room with a laugh.
She walked to The Savoy for tea alone, and sat by the window in her usual seat. As she elegantly sipped her tea and paid her check, she spotted something. It was a figure, almost translucent, and it was staring at her from outside the window. Then, it was joined by four other figures all staring at her shocked face. She put down her teacup and got up from her seat, leaving.
She walked down some streets and over the bridge. She looked down, the Thames gleamed and swirled beneath her feet. She stared at it intently for some minutes, then, taking a deep breath, she jumped.
Now this lady, Alice Adair – or the blue-eyed beauty, as she was more widely known – killed five people in her career as a murderess. Five people: first her mother, who had just come into some wealth from a relative; then her uncle, who had sorted the money with his own in one account; then her father, who had suspected her; then her aunt, who was now in control of all that money. She had done all of this placidly, without flinching, and had even killed her stepbrother, Heath Glass, in the same heartless way. But in the end, what pushed her over the edge was a ghost in a shop window. A ghost of her haunted past: the people she had killed and the price she would now pay, forever entombed in the swirling, murky waters of the Thames, a river famed for swallowing its victims whole. Murderers, conquerors, and innocence itself.
She hadn’t been able to bear that fate. As she’d jumped, she had taken a small pistol out of her purse, put it to her head, and fired.
Runner-up in the Highpoint Scary Short Story Contest, Halloween 2020!